GST EVENT CALENDAR

GST MALAYSIA CALCULATOR

Nuffnang Add

Showing posts with label The Star. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The Star. Show all posts

Friday, May 9, 2014

Preparing for GST


Published: Friday May 9, 2014 MYT 12:00:00 AM 
Updated: Friday May 9, 2014 MYT 7:57:11 AM

The great debate is on : Is the Goods and Services Tax (GST) good for the people?

The government, being the proponent, has been promoting this new broad-based consumption tax for a few years and it finally succeeded in getting the Goods and Services Tax Bill 2014 approved by both the Dewan Rakyat and the Senate on May 5 for implementation on April 1, next year.

The passage of the bill sets into motion a new system to tax all goods made and services rendered in Malaysia including imports except those that are “zero-rated” or exempted from GST.

But I think the debate, with the government on one side and the people on the other, will go on.

The Government’s main contention is that the GST is part of its tax reform programme.

It is careful to explain that although the new system is a multi-stage consumption tax on goods and services, the tax element does not contribute to the cost of the product.

It maintains that the GST of 6% is lower than the combination of 10% Sales Tax and 6% Service Tax that will be replaced and therefore is better.

Wider Net

It also draws strength from the fact that 160 countries in the world have implemented this kind of tax, also called Value Added Tax, and so it must be good.

I agree that it is an efficient system to collect and increase tax revenues because it casts a much wider net to haul in all goods and services unless exempted compared to the current system of taxing specified goods and services that are deemed not essential.

But GST is levied at each stage of the supply chain from the manufacturer to the retailer, each charging 6% tax on the selling price. When the product reaches the consumer, the price will be very much inflated by the tax.

It will not be surprising to see a product leaving its manufacturer at RM100, passing through a wholesaler and a distributor, each adding RM100 for profit plus RM6 for tax, and ending in the hands of the consumer at RM318 (Selling price RM300 plus GST RM18).

Essential items are mostly zero-rated or exempted. Examples are rice, sugar, table salt, flour, cooking oil, vegetable, meats, public transport, healthcare, education and electricity consumption up to 200kwH (about RM50) and 35 cubic metres of water to domestic users per month. The sale and leasing of property are also exempted from GST.

But people do not live on essential items only; they need variety.

Incidentally, many food items sold in supermarkets which we eat daily are not categorised as “essential” and thus subject to GST.

Also, we need to buy clothing, shoes, food supplements, skincare products, household appliances, drinks and gifts during festive seasons, movies and snack on titbits while watchingTV, cookies, repair our cars, and change our laptops and mobile phones.

Consumers will have the burden of paying extra money for the new tax on these important yet non-essential items.

Price hikes

I have no doubt that GST will raise the prices of many items which any average family will spend money on, with the result of erosion of saving for the future.

In fact, the government has admitted that GST will raise the Consumer Price Index by 1.8%. That is an indication that prices may rise and lead to inflation.

Understandably, the people are fearful of yet another round of price hikes after suffering from raised prices of flour, sugar, petrol, cooking oil, electricity, school-bus fares, vegetables, fruits and lately, medical fees.

The monetary aids given by the government do marginally help those of lower income but they are temporary measures whereas the GST is a permanent fixture in the government machinery to generate income.

Government protects small businesses whose annual turnover is below RM500,000 - they are not required to charge GST on their goods and that may attract customers to them.

But the low business volumes put them at disadvantage against supermarkets who command very low wholesale prices.

In the end, people will still shop at supermarkets because their prices, even with GST, are still lower than those of small businesses.

Regressive

This tax system seems to go counter with established principles of taxation.

One of the objectives of taxation is to collect tax from the rich to help the poor and taxing consumption, presumably of the rich, is sensible and noble. But under the GST system, even the poor are similarly taxed.

Even The World Bank has acknowledged that “Value Added Taxation” or “GST” is inherently regressive and that exemptions and zero-rates are ineffective.

So, it appears that we are adopting a regressive tax regime.

Could it be the GST system was effective during the 1980s and 1990s but lost its efficacy in the present due to changes in economic and other conditions?

Moreover, part of the income which has been subjected to income tax will be taxed again by GST if it is spent on non-exempt goods, resulting in double taxation of income.

The worst scenario is that countries implemented GST, but raised them over the years and some of them are now charging as high as 25%.

This, I believe, is the greatest fear of the people. And they will continue to protest the implementation of GST until the next April Fool’s Day.

Examples of how GST works can be found at www.gstmalaysia.co.

Thursday, May 8, 2014

GST is a better tax structure in the long run


Published: Thursday May 8, 2014 MYT 12:00:00 AM 
Updated: Thursday May 8, 2014 MYT 8:01:54 AM

THE 143 countries that have adopted the Goods and Services Tax (GST) are too many to be wrong.

Imagine that had we implemented the GST many years ago and had used the extra taxes to build roads, schools, hospitals, etc, when the costs were very much lower, we would have benefited from it.

The GST is a better tax structure and will in the long run benefit the country.

What makes the people uncomfortable are the excesses incurred by some government departments in their spending as reported by the Auditor-General year after year.

We hope that the Government will make all effort to eradicate or reduce such excesses so that the people will feel comfortable with the extra taxes generated by the GST.

To lessen the burden of the lower income group, the Government should look at ways to alleviate their burden by increasing the welfare payments and the pension rate for the lower level pensioners.

The lower income families should be given a certain amount of money at half yearly intervals.

Senior citizens, above 65 years of age, in Britain are given free passes for bus and railway travel.

There will never be a tax structure that is perfect but we must choose the better one, which is the GST.

THOMAS FOO
Subang Jaya

Introduce luxury car tax for wealthy


Published: Thursday May 8, 2014 MYT 12:00:00 AM 
Updated: Thursday May 8, 2014 MYT 7:59:09 AM

THE GST is an efficient and reliable income source for the Government but it has a great effect on low and low-middle income earners.

My 19 years’ hands-on GST experience in Singapore and my taxation lectures for British and Australian degrees have shown that even zero-rated supplies are affected by input costs. Wages have to be increased due to inflation but consumption tends to decrease. The economic inequality too tends to increase.

A tax system is a fair system where the high income earners, who had benefited from the contributions from the rest of society, should bear a higher tax burden.

Using the argument that other countries use the GST and Malaysia should follow leads to the proposal of the introduction of a “Luxury Car Tax”, as done in Australia.


Owners of luxury cars want the public to recognise their status. The Luxury Car Tax should exempt cars costing less than RM100,000.

Anything in excess should be taxed at a high rate.

This would help the Government pay for the economically weak members of society and for the reduction of the personal and corporate tax rate.

S. THURAISINGAM
Kuala Lumpur

Shoppers’ guide to help consumers understand more about GST


Published: Wednesday May 7, 2014 MYT 12:00:00 AM 
Updated: Wednesday May 7, 2014 MYT 2:55:56 PM
Token of appreciation: (From left) Ahmad Maslan receiving a memento
from Zaini at the end of the programme in Kuching.
KUCHING: In its commitment to assist the people gain better understanding about the impending Goods and Services Tax (GST), the Government will issue a shoppers’ guide three months before the full implementation of the tax on April 1 next year.

The exercise, a collaboration between the Finance Ministry and Domestic Trade, Cooperatives and Consumerism Ministry, is aimed at informing consumers on the list and prices of products affected by the GST.

“This is to avoid consumers being taken advantage by unscrupulous traders,” Deputy Finance Minister Datuk Ahmad Maslan told 150 personnel from the state Communications and Multimedia Ministry office during a GST roadshow here yesterday.

“Through Domestic Trade, Cooperatives and Consumerism Ministry, the move will be under the purview of 2011 Price Control Act and Anti-Competition Act.”

Based on the study undertaken by Customs Department, Ahmad Maslan noted that out of 689 consumer products, 73 or 10% will have tax increase to 6% from the current 5% following the enforcement of GST.

However, 329 products would not be affected.

“In fact, 287 (40%) out of 689 products will see a tax drop to 6% from 10%, while 255 (products) are still being studied.”

On the GST roadshow, Ahmad Maslan said it was one of the ways to educate and raise awareness of GST across all segments of society.

“I have been informed that so far 250,000 people have attended seminars, tours and briefings on GST through the help of various ministries, while the GST portal has reached 250,000 hits,” he added.

Accompanying the deputy minister was state deputy Information director Zaini Mohamad.

Civil servants have right to protest, too


Published: Wednesday May 7, 2014 MYT 12:00:00 AM 
Updated: Wednesday May 7, 2014 MYT 8:16:07 AM

AS a founder member in the formation of the Congress of Unions of Employees in the Public and Civil Services (Cuepacs) and having held the post of secretary-general, I am shocked at the outburst of the Cuepacs president that the civil servants who took part in the anti-GST rally are traitors.

I wish to reiterate that as government servants we have to execute our duties and implement accepted policies of the Government to the best of our ability.

However, it does not preclude our inherent right to object or protest against any government policies we consider detrimental to our interest.

The GST will be detrimental to wage earners, particularly the middle and lower income groups, be it government servants or private sector employees.

This group is already suffering as a result of the rise in the cost of living.

The Government has raised the price of petrol and electricity tariff, which in turn has increased the cost of essential goods.

In fact, Cuepacs should have been in the forefront, together with other workers’ organisations, to protest against the GST.

To members of Cuepacs, my request is do your duties as an honest and responsible government servant.

Do not fear to stand up and fight when your livelihood is affected.

The Chief Secretary to the Government should focus on the millions of ringgit of taxpayers’ money being lost by negligent civil servants, as stated in the Auditor- General’s Report, rather than make idle threats to civil servants and suppress their legitimate right to protest against the GST.

Cuepacs members stand united and stand up for your legitimate right to express dissent.

ATL
Klang

Najib: More GST-exempt items being identified


Published: Tuesday May 6, 2014 MYT 12:00:00 AM 
Updated: Tuesday May 6, 2014 MYT 7:52:56 AM

PUTRAJAYA: The Government is still looking at more items and products that can be exempted from Goods and Services Tax (GST) so as not to unduly burden the people, said Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak.

“We are looking thoroughly at the items and products that could be exempted or zero-rated without affecting the revenue base expansion.

“This way, together with the steps taken to exclude taxes on essential items, the introduction of GST will not burden the people,” he said at the Prime Minister’s Department’s monthly assembly here yesterday.

GST will begin on April 1 next year at a fixed rate of 6%, but essential items, such as rice, sugar, salt, piped water supply, public transportation (bus and train fares), health services and expressway toll, are exempted.

Najib also said the GST awareness campaign would have to be intensified to enlighten the people on its rationale and merits so that no one would protest blindly or object unreasonably.

“As Finance Minister, I know that many are not paying (individual) taxes or are paying less than what they should.

“Some of them, to our naked eyes, look like poor people or earn small salaries, but they can still send their children abroad (at their own expense).

“This means they could have under-declared their income. But this (GST) system is more progressive as it depends on how much our expenses are,” he said, adding that 90% of the countries in the world had found the system effective.

Najib said GST was to help stimulate growth and enable the country to provide more infrastructure and basic needs.

“Tax revenue is required for health care as there is a need to have more hospitals, medical equipment and other urgent needs of the people.

“Adequate revenue is also required to take care of the 1.5 million civil servants, while more expenses are needed for human capital, which is a critical factor in terms of the competitive strength of any country,” he said.

Smokescreening won't work this time


Published: Tuesday May 6, 2014 MYT 12:00:00 AM 
Updated: Tuesday May 6, 2014 MYT 11:30:31 AM

Instead of masking its missteps, Pakatan Rakyat should take some responsibility for the water debacle in Selangor.

MY article published in The Star on April 29 sought to provide clarity over what has proved to be a national embarrassment – that it is 2014 and the richest state in this federation cannot supply water adequately to its people.

I did so, not for some cheap political point scoring but because of Pakatan Rakyat’s continued attempts to blame the Federal Government when the facts really point to the state government’s actions leading us to this unfortunate juncture. And more to the point, in an issue concerning something as basic as water, the people deserve to know how we found ourselves in this mess and how we get out of it.

The article was premised upon two very simple facts. First, the Selangor government’s refusal to allow for tariff increase as provided for in the concession agreements – alongside its failed attempts to purchase water assets – has led to the water companies, especially Syabas, failing to spend adequately to maintain the distribution system and reduce leakages or non-revenue water (NRW).

Second, its refusal to approve the construction of the Langat 2 water treatment plant since 2009 deprived the state of clean water supply it would have otherwise received. (If you remember nothing else from this article, remember that).

True to form, the Pakatan PR machinery moved into overdrive and within a day, we saw two responses – from Damansara Utama assemblyman Yeo Bee Yin and a former staffer to the Mentri Besar, Nathaniel Tan.

YB Yeo’s first accusation: the current water shortage is due to the change in rain pattern as a result of climate change. She believes that the water crisis is not due to demand growth as projected, implying that the Federal Government shouldn’t try to take credit for forecasting this exact problem years ago.

I’m not certain what her point is. Obviously, when forecasting supply and demand, one tries to take into account all factors and contingencies. Demand has been steadily increasing since 1998 at around 4% per annum and to suddenly blame climate change is a cop out.

The fact of the matter is – we forecasted the current water shortage in 2009 and advised them to relook their populist, cheap water policy. We even offered them an exit: Langat 2. What we got in return were statements like those of state exco YB Elizabeth Wong rubbishing the warnings back in 2011.

There is a related argument that points to other states having water supply issues, such as Johor and Negeri Sembilan – as if to suggest we should cut Selangor some slack. Two quick points: first, any disruption in supply in Johor and Negeri Sembilan have not been anywhere as severe and protracted as Selangor’s. Second, while we can link Johor’s water concerns directly to the drought due to the river’s proximity to the sea (meaning that a drop in water levels can lead to salt water going upstream), in Selangor, we saw dam levels drop since May 2013, way before any dry season. The point stands: there were warning signs for Selangor and there was a way out but they just didn’t want to take it.

YB Yeo’s second accusation: The water tariff in Selangor is already the second highest in the country and Syabas’ inability to reduce NRW is because it has been “misusing public money” – implying that tariff increases will be uncalled for.

It is true that the tariff is the second highest after Johor, even without tariff increases. But what Pakatan doesn’t want you to consider is that the piping network in Selangor accounts for 20% of the entire national network, what with it being the most populous and industrialised state with the largest economy. Never mind the fact that tariff increases are embedded in the concession agreements – as a regulating mechanism – clearly, the Selangor tariffs would be higher than Perak, Perlis or even Penang, which has been getting loans from the federal government (something they also don’t want you to consider).

What they further fail to mention is that NRW had fallen from 37.8% in 2005 to 33.1% in 2012 despite the natural deterioration (that is, NRW increases if no efforts are done) of 1.8% per annum. Curiously enough, YB Yeo acknowledged that Selangor needs RM540mil to reduce the NRW to the 15% target. Where does she or Nathaniel think the money is supposed to come from if it isn’t from the tariff increases?

YB Yeo’s third accusation: Langat 2 would only come on stream in 2015 and hence, would not solve the current problem.

Simple fact: had the state government not dragged its feet on awarding the Development Order since 2009, Langat 2 would have been operational now, providing an extra 1,130mil litres daily and avoiding the crisis today.

YB Yeo’s fourth accusation: despite the Federal Government taking over the bonds at RM6.2bil and injecting RM400mil for operations, Syabas has not reduced NRW sufficiently.

The RM6.2bil was to take over the bonds of the four water operators to avoid an adverse impact on the capital market and the RM400mil was for operational improvements, specifically to pay for the treated water it obtained from the three water operators since the state government rejected their application for a tariff increase. They had absolutely nothing to do with NRW reduction.

Now, it is true that we cannot keep throwing government money at problems. But there are times where the Government needs to spend to avoid a total collapse of an industry, such as would have been the case without the RM6.2bil injection to service bondholders.

Nathaniel claims the term “bailout” is more appropriate than “cash injection”, which I had initially used. I guess he is half-right – we did bail out the state government, which, in its politicking, was prepared to see precisely the water industry collapse we wanted to avoid.

YB Yeo’s fifth accusation: The Federal Government should not claim credit for agreeing to provide RM9.65bil to acquire the water companies but release assets to the state government.

First off, isn’t it telling that – just as its first accusation about water shortage forecast – Pakatan is clearly less concerned about how to move forward than it is with making sure it gains maximum political dividend? Isn’t it telling that even when the Federal Government agrees to set aside RM9.65bil to, again, bail out the state government and help it fulfil its election promises, they still find ways to blame us for it?

Bandying around terms like “unbridled greed of BN-linked corporate players” and “decades of corruption and cronyism”, they engineer smokescreens to hide a simple business fact in any modern economy: that a purchase arrangement needs to be on a willing buyer, willing seller basis. If they need any further evidence of that, they needn’t look very far as it is found in their repeated and futile attempts to acquire water assets below fair value since taking over in 2008.

Whether it is issues like tariffs or something altogether different like GST, the standard line of “BN corrupt” just doesn’t cut it any more when the facts don’t stack up and the numbers don’t add up.

In this unfortunate Selangor case, taking some responsibility is the first step to ensuring the crisis ends – because guess what? Pakatan could still drag its feet on Langat 2 and despite the recent end to water rationing, we might be back here in six months.

> Khairy Jamaluddin is the Youth and Sports Minister as well as the Barisan Nasional Youth Chairman. Contrary to popular belief, his house was also affected by water cuts.

Boosting ties through trade fair


Published: Tuesday May 6, 2014 MYT 12:00:00 AM 
Updated: Tuesday May 6, 2014 MYT 12:56:57 PM
Committed to serve: Committee members of the Penang Importers and
Exporters Association taking their oath for the term 2014/2015 in George Town.
T HE Penang Importers and Exporters Association (PIEA) is planning to organise an import and export exhibition in the state.

Its new president Ng Hooi Lai said the exhibition would be a great trade platform for local importers and exporters if such an exhibition were to be held in the state.

“As the new president, I want to do the best for the association and it has always been an ambition of mine to organise such an exhibition.

“We can invite suppliers from all over the world to meet our members and set up trade relations,” he said after a swearing-in ceremony for PIEA’s 2014/2015 committee members at a hotel in George Town recently.

Hooi Lai said there had been no such exhibition which concentrated solely on importers and exporters, adding that his aim was to promote the association to the best of his ability and at the same time, get more members to join.

“We are also educating the members on the Goods and Services Tax or GST which will be implemented next year.”

He also promised that the association would carry out more programmes that would benefit the association and its members.

PIEA, which started 60 years ago, currently has some 240 members.

Also present was Tanjong MP Ng Wei Aik, who said importers and exporters should keep abreast of current issues and changes in the business world such as the Trans-Pacific Partnership Agreement that was under discussion and the GST.

“These will affect the association members. So, it is important to be up-to-date on such changes,” he said in his opening speech.

PM: More goods and services could be exempted from GST


Published: Monday May 5, 2014 MYT 9:34:00 AM 
Updated: Monday May 5, 2014 MYT 9:41:03 AM

PUTRAJAYA: The list of goods and services that will be taxed under the GST is still being finalised, said Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak.

He also said there could be more goods and services that would not be listed under the Goods and Service Tax (GST).

"We are working to see if there could be more items that can be declared zero rated.

"The GST is not to burden the people," he said at the Prime Minister's Department monthly assembly here Monday.

Najib said the road show on the GST would also continue to provide the public with information on the system.

The 6% GST is expected to be implemented next year.

GST has benefits, consumers told to spend wisely


Published: Sunday May 4, 2014 MYT 3:37:00 PM 
Updated: Sunday May 4, 2014 MYT 4:29:13 PM

IPOH: The implementation of the Goods and Services Tax (GST) next year can help to prevent money laundering and black money.

Second Finance Minister Datuk Seri Dr Ahmad Husni Hanadzlah's special assistant Ting Tai Fook (pic) said the GST was transparent and that all items paid and charged would be printed out in an invoice.

"In the current Sales and Service Tax (SST), the items paid do not show how much tax was charged for each item as the sales tax is already embedded in the sales price.

"With the GST, the printed invoice will show which items have been charged the 6% tax," he said, during a forum on GST at the Tower Regency Hotel here on Sunday. 

"We also have a programme used in the GST system that can differentiate the standard and exempted items and charge these accordingly," he said.

"We have studied the GST system implemented in about 160 countries and came up with a perfect system," he added.

Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak announced that the GST would be implemented beginning April 1 next year.

Ting stressed that consumers should always need to be wise when making purchases.

"We always urged the people to spend wisely and to spend at the right time. 

"Check and compare prices, or wait for the items to have discounted price," he said.

"Whether it is buying a cup of coffee from a well-known coffee chain for about RM10, or a cup at your regular coffeeshop for about RM1.80, no one can force you to choose either one," Ting said.

"At the end of the day, it is up to the consumers to make the right decision," he added.

Peace and order at GST gathering


Published: Sunday May 4, 2014 MYT 12:00:00 AM 
Updated: Sunday May 4, 2014 MYT 8:52:27 AM
Peaceful assembly: Barring a minor scuffle, the anti-GST rally on Thursday
was a peaceful one. The police were around but seemed rather friendly and accommodating.
It wasn’t too long ago when demonstrations and rallies in public places were frowned upon by the authorities. But with the Peaceful Assembly Act in place, the police seem to have come to terms with the fact that public assembly is a right and is here to stay.

AT the end of the anti-GST rally at Dataran Merdeka on Labour Day, Suhakam commissioner James Nayagam was in high spirits and rejoicing.

Calling the rally a success, the beaming Nayagam says both the police and the organisers of the rally had kept to their word, which enabled the public assembly to go on peacefully.

“I give the police an ‘A’ for their handling of this rally. The police were there. They were very professional and were talking to the people. There was a free flow of persons coming in and out of the area. They didn’t stop anyone. People could freely assemble and express themselves. The police allowed and facilitated the assembly.

“I don’t think there is anything more that the police can improve on,” says Nayagam, who is a “veteran of sorts” at monitoring rallies, demonstrations and public assemblies, having monitored 35 of these in the last few years.

He is the Suhakam commissioner in charge of complaints, monitoring and inquiries.

He also gives the anti-GST rally organisers an “A”.

“The organisers had gone to the negotiating table and come to an agreement with the police about the time of the rally, what time it would end, that they would not cross into the Dataran Merdeka field and that it would be a peaceful assembly.

“And they honoured their word. They came, spoke and left. They passed the test,” he says.

It’s been just a little over two years when Dataran Merdeka was transformed into a different scene altogether, on April 28, 2012, during the Bersih 3.0 rally.

Back then, the police had put up barricades and razor wires in strategic areas to stop protesters from getting too close to Dataran Merdeka. There was a heavy police presence and FRU trucks and FRU personnel were standing by in their full anti-riot gear.

Things turned violent when some protesters breached the police barricades to try and get to Dataran Merdeka, and the police responded by unleashing their water cannons and firing 961 canisters of tear gas into the packed crowd of tens of thousands, who were running helter-skelter to escape the chaos.

The police also chased and hit a number of protesters, and the media were not spared either. This time around, there was none of that. There were no razor wires, no FRU, no water cannons, no tear gas. The police were around but seemed rather friendly and accommodating.

And the protesters were allowed to gather at Dataran Merdeka, although not on the field itself because that area was cordoned off as it was being renovated and deemed unsafe. There were nails on the field and, Nayagam says, a policeman had accidentally stepped on one earlier.

While the rally overall was peaceful, there was a bit of trouble when a group of youngsters wearing Solidarity Anak Muda Malaysia (SAMM) t-shirts tried to get onto the field. But they were stopped and held back by PAS’ Unit Amal security volunteers and a brief scuffle broke out between the two sides.

Nayagam dismisses this as an “isolated incident”, saying that in such big gatherings, there was bound to be a few individuals who wanted “to stretch the limit”.

Drawing a parallel, he says that every time there is a wedding in Brickfields, without fail there would be a group of trouble-makers who gatecrash, push the tables and demand for food, but that does not mar the wedding.

Similarly, the small group of unruly youths did not mar the success of the public rally because the rest were well-behaved.

He credits PAS’ Unit Amal for a job well done in pushing the unruly youths away and not allowing them to get on the field.

“An agreement is an agreement. The organisers agreed and accepted that the field was off limits. That was the only rule the police made – ‘Don’t cross into the field’.

“If the Unit Amal hadn’t pushed them back and the youths had entered the field, and if the police and law enforcement moved in, then the whole thing would have gone berserk because that would have given a wrong signal and all hell would have broken loose,” he says.

Nayagam remembers all too well how, in 2012 during Bersih 3.0, hell broke loose. He says it gave him nightmares and he never wants a repeat of that dreadful day.

So, understandably, he is calling on the organisers of the Labour Day anti-GST rally to do a post-mortem – identify and haul up the group of unruly youths and take them to task.

“That kind of behaviour is unbecoming. It causes a lot of unrest, can disrupt a well-meaning gathering and give a bad name to all. So we want the organisers to inform Suhakam of the action they have taken against that group,” he says.

A noticeable change

Since the chaos of Bersih 3.0 and the flak the police received for using disproportionate force to disperse crowds, there has been a noticeable change in the police handling of public assemblies.

Nayagam says there is an apparent openness now on the side of the police.

For the anti-GST rally, he notes that it was the police who invited the organisers in for discussions, which is “something that never existed before in the past”.

“We notice too that there is an openness to discuss. Previously, it was only one-sided with the police saying ‘No, cannot’. But now there is an openness of both parties to discuss and come to an agreement.”

He adds that perception towards public assemblies has shifted too.

“Previously, you can’t even talk or dream about a public assembly.”

There has also been an awareness on the part of the police of people having the right to assemble and some respect for human rights.

“The police can’t be using force all the time. Using the ‘cane’ over time has become meaningless. Society has changed and the police likewise is responding to what has changed in society,” he says.

Other than the anti-GST rally, Nayagam says this change is also noticeable in four other public assemblies, the Himpunan Hijau walk from Kuantan to Dataran Merdeka to protest against the Lynas Rare Earth plant, the Kelana Jaya stadium 505 rally after the 2013 general election, the Black 505 rally at Padang Merbok and the New Year Eve protest against the rising cost of living at Dataran Merdeka.

One point people seem to miss is the fact that the present Home Minister Datuk Dr Zahid Hamidi himself is a former student leader and a protester in the 1970s when he was at university at the height of the university students’ protest days.

So, unlike the other Home Ministers, Zahid’s unique background has probably put him in a better position to understand the psychology of protesters better.

At the heart of the Labour Day protest, of course, is the GST (the Goods and Services Tax) which is due to be implemented next April.

The GST is seen as a broader and fairer tax system because taxes are based on what people consume.

But, more importantly, essential food items like rice, flour, cooking oil, vegetable, meat, and fish will all be zero-rated, which means there will be no GST for these. Essential services like public transport, toll, hospital, schools and residential housing will also be GST tax-exempt.

Yet that message has not reached the common folks – at least not those who came for the anti-GST protest rally – who believe the new tax system will hike up prices of food and other essential items.

“The GST is a tax that will make us, the poor, even poorer,” says Maziah, who came from Taiping for the rally with her husband. She complains that the price of rubber has gone down to RM1.80 per kg and rubber tappers like her are already finding it hard to make ends meet.

She fears she will not be able to afford food and basic items once the GST comes into play. “We are rich in resources like rubber, palm oil and oil and timber. Why can’t the Government use income from this to build the roads, schools and for development projects? Why squeeze us even more?”

But Robinson Rodriguez, 56, who was also at the rally, says he is not totally against the GST. Rather, he has doubts over its implementation and whether an effective system is in place to stop businesses from profiteering.

“I agree we need to do something to bring down our trade deficit. But how sure are we that the money we pay for the GST will go to the right coffers?

“Corruption has become such a disease in the country. We need to address this first, otherwise no matter how much money the Government has or gets, it will never be enough because it will be whittled away by corruption,” he says.

He points out that even if it is a consumption-based tax, it is always the lower income group who will feel the brunt because they would be the ones who have to watch what they consume and cut down on the extras, while the rich will not bother.

Rodriguez feels that a more gradual approach of the GST would be more palatable.

“Say, when you implement, you start it low at 3% first, then gradually up it to 4%, 5% then later 6% over the years instead of the proposed 6%. That will give people time to understand how it works, get used to it and allow the authorities to iron out the chinks in the implementation.

“And if the country goes bust, we won’t die. We will find a way and survive as a nation,” he says.

The good, the bad and the ugly of tax


Published: Sunday May 4, 2014 MYT 12:00:00 AM 
Updated: Sunday May 4, 2014 MYT 7:11:14 AM

IN less than a year, the Goods and Services Tax (GST) will be a reality. Come April 1, 2015, Malaysia will join the ranks of some 160 countries in having this form of tax system.

In fact, some 90% of the world’s population already live in countries with GST or Value-Added Tax. In a sense, therefore, we are not venturing into new territory.

But any form of taxation, be it new or simply revised upwards, is bound to evoke an emotional response.

The anti-GST rally held on May 1 is indicative of such a response. While we should respect the right to peaceful assembly as a means to articulate one’s grievances, we also need to ask if those present fully understand how GST works, and how they will be personally impacted.


It is never easy to explain things in a rational manner when certain quarters play the populist card to the hilt. After all, they are not the ones who have to administer the painful medicine necessary to boost the country’s economic health.

The Malaysian population has just crossed 30 million but only about 5.6% or 1.7 million of the country’s population pay income tax. Figures from the Inland Revenue Board reveal that only one million Malaysian employees pay tax although there are four million employees with income tax files.

Similarly, of the 450,000 companies that have files in the IRB, only 75,000 companies are classified as eligible taxpayers.

This being tax season, we hear the usual lament about how those who are employed and taxed upfront pay more because they do not have tax consultants to help them minimise their tax liability. We have anecdotal evidence about the entrepreneur driving a luxury car who probably pays less tax than the senior manager he employs.

There may be creative ways to file one’s tax returns so as to fall out of the tax bracket but the GST will at least ensure that those who spend more on goods and services, based on their consumption patterns and habits, will contribute to our tax coffers.

And that include tax evaders, prosperous businessmen-hawkers who don’t pay income tax, and even the neighbourhood soya bean milk seller who is able to send his children overseas on his own expenses.

What is important, however, is to tell the ordinary person that he does not have to pay GST for a packet of nasi lemak or char koay teow. And that there will be some 3,000 exceptions or zero-rated products such as food items when the GST is implemented.

From what has been revealed so far, basic products including rice, sugar, salt, piped water supply, bus, train, health services and highway tolls will not be included in the list.

In short, if you live a simple lifestyle based on needs rather than wants, the GST is not going to hurt your pockets the way the political opportunists seem to suggest.

The government needs to do a better job communicating this message across to the masses. Putting up billboards, publishing the occasional articles, or having seminars and confe­rences will not help the ordinary people understand the issues.

Our politicians, whichever side of the divide, should work together to ensure that what is collected is well managed and spent, without the wastage and leakages that are regularly revealed by the Auditor-General.

When it comes to the economy, we need to be in one accord to steer the Malaysian economy out of choppy waters.

Be positive and count our blessings


Published: Sunday May 4, 2014 MYT 12:00:00 AM 
Updated: Sunday May 4, 2014 MYT 7:09:44 AM

We can whine and complain about things, or we can review the many luxuries we have conveniently classified as essentials. To be positive is not to deny the negative. It is simply acknowledging that there are many people in worse circumstances than us.

AN archaeologist is the best husband any woman can have; the older she gets, the more interested he is in her.

Everyone in the ballroom erupted in cheers when the father of the bridegroom, who is known to us as quite a serious man, closed his speech with this quote by Agatha Christie.

It concluded a very heartfelt and moving speech. This father certainly had good lessons to pass on to his son and his daughter-in-law, and I was inspired.


I quietly took out my little 555 notebook and jotted down some of the salient points he made.

And as I looked through the pages I was transported back to one wedding dinner some months back that took place in the heart of Putrajaya.

My good friend from school days was the host and in typical Malaysian fashion, he had to start his speech with salutations to all the VIPs present.

It has been said that a speech should be like a skirt – long enough to cover all the essential parts and short enough to be appealing.

I remember my friend’s speech well because he kept to the three-point formula.

Those of us who have to sit through long speeches know that any speaker who ventures beyond the three points basically loses the attention of the audience.

Even if he is accompanied by a PowerPoint presentation, it is a matter of time before we murmur: “No power, no point!”

The three valuable lessons that my friend imparted to his son that evening were – be positive, be purposeful and be passionate.

The editor in me immediately noticed the alliteration, an important element in public speaking to make the message stick.

I paid particular attention to the story my friend shared about how to be positive.

“If you think you can, you can and if you think you can’t you are probably right,” he said.

“Challenges will come your way. It is said so poignantly that there is no life into which some rain has not fallen. All sunshine makes a desert.

“Obstacles are opportunities for growth. Stumbling blocks are stepping stones. It is the rough seas that make good sailors. Pain produces endurance, endurance, character and character, hope.”

I am sure many were inspired by his speech that night. It is a lesson that applies to all of us.

We can whine about the inconvenience of water rationing, or we can learn that it is not so difficult to build a simple contraption to harvest rainwater. And that we really need not wash our cars every day.

We can complain about GST, or we can review the many luxuries we have conveniently classified as essentials.

In the process, we can perhaps become more sensitive to the people around us who still struggle to earn in a month what some of us may earn in a day.

To be positive is not to deny the negative. It is simply acknowledging that there are many people in worse circumstances than us.

That, in itself, would make us count our blessings.

> Executive editor Soo Ewe Jin (ewejin@thestar.com.my) remembers the time when the emcee at a friend’s wedding dinner declared after the last course: “And now, we have come to the end of the marriage…” Thankfully, this couple is still happily married after nearly three decades.

Planners and officers must go to the ground


Published: Sunday May 4, 2014 MYT 12:00:00 AM 
Updated: Sunday May 4, 2014 MYT 9:04:12 AM

Officers must make turun padang part and parcel of their duties to disseminate the message and mechanism of new development policies.


THE recent kidnapping of two foreign tourists at the Singamata Reef Resort, off Semporna, happening barely a year after the formation of the Eastern Sabah Security Command (Esscom), prompted me to pen this article.

The public service is the backbone of the machinery that runs the country. Many well-meaning policies may be lost in effect if implementation is not carried out properly as public administrators are essentially the backbone of the delivery system.

Malayan (since 1963 Malaysian) nation building has been based on a process of deliberate and elaborate development planning. Beginning with the five-year First Malaya Plan 1956-60, we are now into the fourth year of the Tenth Malaysia Plan (2011-15). In between the five-year plans, there are the Mid-Term Reviews to fine-tune the projects in line with changing economic conditions.

Then there are the sectoral and regional plans such as the Industrial Master Plans and the Regional Development Plans of Pahang Tenggara and Johor Tenggara, etc. And, of course, there is always the all-important Annual Budget.

As one involved in inputs to the planning process (in my academic days) in the 1970s and 80s and debates on the planning strategies since the 90s, I cannot help but lament the fact that, after more than five decades of nation building, the planning process has now attained a life of its own in the public service structure.

Presenting the plan has almost become the end in itself.


Over the last two decades, the increasingly complex institutional structure has induced a long line of communication between planners and implementers, blurring the sense of urgency for delivery and impact of many plans.

Witness our “rubber-rejuvenation and the introduction of oil palm as the second crop” period of 1965-80, in response to the challenge posed by the (then) newly developed synthetic rubber.

Under the late Tun Abdul Razak Hussein’s “Green Book” developmental strategy and mobilising the massive outreach of our agriculture extension apparatus, Malaysia evolved in a short time to be the world’s largest producer of natural rubber and palm oil. (Of course, we have now been overtaken by Indonesia.) During this period, the acreages planted and replanted (of rubber and palm oil) were checked at district levels by the District Officers almost monthly.

And in the early 1980s when we first launched our industrialisation drive, the acreages of industrial estates and Free Trade Zones developed were checked against targets at least on a semi-annual basis.

Of course, it can be argued that planning for nation building four decades ago was a much simpler process. Planners back then only had to interact with the likes of the UK’s Kew Gardens and our Rubber Research Institute for agricultural innovations. Implementers could then focus on ensuring that farmers and small-holders adopted the new clones.

For manufacturing, we could rely on the Multi-national Corporations (MNCs) to bring in investments with suitable incentives.

But we are now in the creativity and innovation era.

Our public servants have to interact with the wizards of Silicon Valley, researchers at the Stanford, MIT and Cambridge research centres to detect and decipher the wave of emerging industries and activities. This requires training as well as verbal and quantitative skills of a much higher order.

Being now rather detached from the emerging engines of the future, our public administration apparatus has also become far too complex.

Planners in KL have not been able to communicate fully and directly on their planned goals to the implementers and outreach officers at the district and mukim levels.

Knowledge of plans and programmes among SMEs

Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) are a crucial part of an economy. In Malaysia as at 2011, SMEs accounted for 97.3% of the total of 662,939 establishments. The sector contributed to about 33% of the GDP. For the period 2006 to 2012, the average annual growth rate of SMEs was 6.3%, higher than the average growth rate of the economy of 4.7%.

Chart 1 shows the strong correlation between SME growth and the overall GDP growth although it is unclear if the economy is driven largely by SMEs or that GDP is driving SME growth.

Barring the causality effect of the two variables, Malaysia is behind many Asian countries in terms of SMEs’ contribution to GDP, as shown in Chart 2.

Japan’s SME contribution is about 55%, with South Korea and Hong Kong both at 49%. Malaysia’s 31% is rather low by comparison.

Certainly Malaysia is not lacking in ideas and development programmes tailored for SMEs. Among them, we have the Enrichment and Enhancement programmes, Green LED programmes, National Mark of Malaysian Brand programme, Skills Upgrading, Women Entrepreneurship, Youth Entrepreneurship programmes and the numerous soft loans, and bridging loans for hundreds of different types of industries ranging from manufacturing to retail to services.

What is the reason for the relatively low Malaysian SME contribution to GDP then?

To answer this question, in mid-December 2013 the KL Centre for Strategic Engagement (CENSE) conducted a survey among SMEs in the Klang Valley to assess their understanding of government programmes and policies. In line with the electricity tariff hike announced on Dec 1, CENSE wanted to assess the SME’s understanding of an essential utility such as electricity and TNB’s role in electricity supply.

A total of 244 SMEs in the services and informal sectors were surveyed on their understanding of the overall electricity policy direction and planning. Face-to-face interviews were conducted using guided structured questions.

The results (see Chart 3) are a stark reminder that the gap between policies intended for the well-being of the consumers and the “buy-in” couldn’t be further apart.

About 77% of the SME respondents asked in the Klang Valley had never heard of the Feed-in Tariff (FiT) for renewable energy. This means they have been paying the 1.6% surcharge in their electricity bills without knowing what it is, let alone what it is intended for.

Over 73% of SMEs think the government hasn’t done enough to inform them of the changes in tariffs, although Malaysia has one of the lowest electricity tariffs in Asia, and the hikes were only announced after many months of publicity campaign in mainstream newspapers and other media.

If a basic item such as electricity hasn’t been well explained, what about more complex policies like GST, minimum wages, subsidy rationalisation, security measures and, for that matter, economic transformation?



Refocusing on programme delivery

Recognising where the gaps exist between policy planning and policy implementation is crucial. Is this the time for a Public Service Transformation?

Having spoken to many distinguished senior public servants, I believe that the missing link is the need for a serious re-orientation of our governance system from one focusing on planning to one focusing on the sense of urgency on outreach, delivery and impact.

What is required is a new mission of Service Delivery with Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) based on grassroots understanding and acceptance of policies for national transformation, such the GST; and the subsidy rationalisation as well as KPIs for adoption of policy tools intended for economic progress, such as those for improving energy efficiency and increasing productivity.

Every plan must have detailed KPIs on the expected end results, and the mechanism required to achieve the desired delivery results and impacts.

I also believe the public service needs to re-learn some of the traditional outreach strategies to disseminate the message and mechanism of new policies, instead of merely relying on expensive TV and radio advertising which have limited effect in terms of holding the attention of the rakyat.

The traditional practice of people-to-people contacts is tedious but effective. This means that planners and officers should “get out of the desks” regularly, and not just accompany Ministers when they are in town. They must make turun padang a part and parcel of their duties.

Priority should be given to holding frequent town-hall and neighbourhood meetings with residential associations, guilds and associations, NGOs and key opinion leaders.

In particular, Pemandu’s brainstorming laboratories should be expanded to the local council, district and mukim levels. This would enable all segments of society to contribute new ideas towards local and national development on issues such as job generation, security and environmental protection, etc. At the same time, their perceptions (and degree of acceptance) of planned government programmes could also be assessed.

Besides using Bahasa Malaysia and English, outreach officers should also use the vernacular languages and dialects of the locality where necessary to generate greater understanding and eventual acceptance of the intended policies.

The messages can then be followed by coverage in newspapers, radio, TV and online media. These can then be tweeted and re-tweeted via the social media.

More importantly, we need to institutionalise into our public service delivery system the sense of urgency and purpose of all the plans we have. The public service must also be fully empowered to implement the plans in accordance with the agreed mechanism for them to succeed.

This will ensure the plans are carried out promptly for the benefit of the rakyat.

>Tan Sri Dr Fong Chan Onn was Prof of Applied Economics and Dean of Faculty of Economics and Administration, Universiti Malaya. He served as Deputy Education Minister (1990-1999) and Human Resources Minister (1999-2008).

Sabah SMEs have grownpast five years


Published: Saturday May 3, 2014 MYT 11:39:00 AM 
Updated: Saturday May 3, 2014 MYT 11:42:17 AM

KOTA KINABALU: The small and medium enterprises (SMEs) sector in Sabah has grown by 65 per cent in the past five years with 40,884 such establishments currently operating in the state.

Minister of Special Tasks in the Chief Minister's Department Datuk Teo Chee Kangsaid in terms of numbers, Sabah ranked sixth among all the 13 states in the country.

"The SMEs in the state are also more diversified covering many sectors including the manufacturing, agriculture, services, mining and quarrying and, construction sectors," he said at SME 100 Awards 2014 presentation last night.

In helping the SMEs, he said the government would continue to focus on capacity building, financial assistance, market development, facilitation of export and brand development, skill and entrepreneurial training, as well as, provide necessary infrastructure, institutional and regulatory support for business to flourish.

"At the same time, the government is also determined to ensure that our SMEs remain competitive globally and resilient to external shocks and uncertainties," he added.

Teo said the Malaysia Global Innovation and Creative Centre (MaGIC) launched in Cyberjaya jointly by Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak and United StatePresident Barack Obama last week, was a one stop centre to empower entrepreneurs.

The state government would continue to work closely with the Federal government and its agencies to enable SMEs to take advantage of all the numerous assistance and incentives extended by the government.

"At the same time, I strongly urge our SMEs to be proactive and more aggressive in developing and expanding their business domestically and internationally.

"As all of you are well aware, most of the successful multinational companies today started off as SMEs," he said.

He also advised SMEs to prepare for the Goods and Services Tax (GST) which be implemented on April 1, 2015.

Teo added that the introduction of the GST was important to have a clear understanding of the general mechanism of the new system so that necessary adjustments can made.

At the event, 31 SMEs from Sabah and Sarawak were announced winners of the annual award, organised by SME Magazine,

Among the award recipients were Airworld Travel and Tours Sdn Bhd, Mega United Resources Sdn Bhd, Pembinaan D.G.E Sdn Bhd, SM Health Care Sdn Bhd, Timplas Industries (M) Sdn Bhd and Ulink Ascot Sdn Bhd. - BERNAMA

Amway claws back its profits


Published: Saturday May 3, 2014 MYT 12:00:00 AM 
Updated: Saturday May 3, 2014 MYT 10:12:51 AM
Paul Yee
AS Amway (M) Holdings recovers from the global financial crisis in 2008, it faces problems of other sorts.

Direct-selling companies in Malaysia have been hit by the strain on the wallets of consumers but Amway intends to persevere with what helped it recover from those troubling times a few years ago.

“In the 2008-2009 crisis, Amway undertook several initiatives to turn adversity to our long-term advantage with investments in new Amway shops, a major advertising campaign and increased sales and marketing programmes,” general manager Paul Yee says.

In that year, Amway also further improved business engagement with its distributors by accepting all credit card payments.

“This increased spending, together with the unfavourable exchange rate with the US dollar, lower interest income from the lower interest rate environment, and higher bank charges from acceptance of all credit cards were the reasons that impacted our profitability in 2009,” says Yee.

In 2009, Amway’s net profit dropped by 31% to RM72.5mil from RM95.1mil the previous year due to the global financial crisis.

Despite the setback, Amway proved itself to still be profitable as it saw earnings climbed steadily, posting a growth rate of between 7.4% and 13% each subsequent year.

Amway is growing after the last crisis, even as other retailers continue to struggle due to higher cost of living.

Companies such as Zhulian, Cosway, Avon and Amway make money through selling products ranging from fabric softeners to anti-aging creams.

“Situations like the above works well for direct selling as tough times and rising costs will put pressure on a person to look for additional income. Direct selling offers this opportunity to people.

“It also provides an entrepreneurial opportunity for anyone who wants to own and run a business,” he says.

As of 2012, Amway had about 244,000 core distributors, and that number has been growing steadily by about 5% each year since 2008.

When the GST is introduced in 2015, it would have an impact on the group’s business, as it will dampen buying sentiment.

“We hope there will be a reduction in income tax rates to help consumers and the elimination of other taxes like sales tax and excise duty.

“It will still mean higher cost of goods but it will also mitigate the adverse effect. In time, consumer will come to live with it as it will become a norm,” Yee notes.

As Amway’s profit grew, so did its cash balance. As of December 2013, the group is sitting on a RM152.88mil cash pile.

However, it is not planning on any expansion or mergers but will continue to use its money to build more Amway shops which costs around RM500,000 per store.

“Other than that, we don’t buy new companies. We’re very focused on direct selling and we’re not distracted by mergers and acquisitions,” Yee stresses.

The group’s share price has also steadily increased since its listing, having shot up to RM12.40 in August 2013, in tandem with its steadily increasing top and bottom line.

“The share price reflects shareholders’ confidence in the company. We are amazed at how stable our share price is. It’s a good testimony as shareholders regard us as a very safe and strong company to invest in.

“Sometimes all we hear is the ‘unhappiness’ from shareholders as they can’t get enough shares as it’s not very liquid,” he jokes.

Meanwhile, Kenanga Research in a report has pegged Amway as a market perform but remains neutral on the group because of the high product cost outlook as a result of the strengthening US dollar.

This comes despite Amway’s continuous effort to grow its sales by enhancing the accessibility of products and brands, new product introductions and continuous sales and marketing programmes.

It has maintained Amway’s net profit estimates of RM111.3mil for its financial year 2014, and RM121mil for 2015.

“Growth would be mainly supported by expected higher distributor productivity riding on the company’s successful sales and marketing programmes,” it says.

Touching on its growth story, Yee is looking forward to keep the group in its growth trend and tries very hard to make this year another successful one. Besides targeting the younger segment, Amway is also looking into penetrating the bumiputra market and has been actively promoting programmes to encourage growth in this area.

“It’s a strategy that we have put forth since 2010 as we see the bumi market as having big potential. Since we started, we have seen double-digit growth for this segment.

“Currently our Chinese segment still contributes the most but we do recognise the bumi market as the larger one as 63% of Malaysians are Malays,” he says.

With prudent management coupled with careful spending, it is easy to see how Amway manages to pay substantial dividends to its shareholders, with last year’s payout amounting to 94% or RM102.74mil of its total net earnings for the year.

“We will pay no less than 80% of our profit to shareholders,” says Yee,

The group posted a 4.6% increase in revenue to RM834.22mil for the year ended Dec 31, 2013 from RM797.2mil a year before, while profit was up 9.34% to RM109.08mil from RM99.74mil in 2012.

For 2014, Amway is targeting a low single-digit growth but Yee is keeping his fingers crossed for a double-digit growth.

Considering the group’s age, it has managed to stay relevant to today’s market after almost four decades in Malaysia.

“For continuity, we must keep ourselves in pace and refresh ourselves constantly,” he says.