GST EVENT CALENDAR

GST MALAYSIA CALCULATOR

Nuffnang Add

Showing posts with label Malaysia Chronicle. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Malaysia Chronicle. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 23, 2014

Property to COST MORE due to GST - MCA warns



Building material and cost of labour will be subjected to the impending goods and services tax (GST), which MCA warned will increase prices of residential properties.

"Though residential property is exempted, the material cost like cement, steel, bricks, labour work will be subjected to GST and the developer will not be able to claim any input tax credit.

"As such, the government should look into the possibility of zero rating on affordable homes to reduce the impact of GST to home buyers," said MCA vice-president Chua Tee Yong in a press release today.

Chua, a trained accountant and second term MP for Labis, also urged the government to ensure that residential buildings built on commercial land be exempted from GST.

"Commercial land in Klang Valley, Penang and also Johor are being used to build residential condominiums due to scarcity of land.

"This will invariably raise the new property price if standard rate of 6 percent GST applies," he said.

He added that discussions with various interest groups recently revealed that the GST may also be imposed on parking lots, furniture and fittings for new condominiums.

"Should this be true, incurring an additional GST of RM1,200 for a car park lot, which cost RM20,000, would be passed on to home buyers via the sale price although residential properties is GST exempted.

"Therefore I call upon the government to address these issues, explains to the public and conduct comprehensive consultation with the relevant stakeholders to seek appropriate solutions that will benefit everyone," he said.

The GST Bill has been passed by the Dewan Rakyat and is scheduled for implementation on April 2015.



-Malaysiakini

Tuesday, April 8, 2014

CRONY 5? 'Only five highway operators make money' - Works minister


Monday, 07 April 2014 17:42

Only five out of 30 highway concessionaires in the country were making a profit, the government claimed today.

Works Minister Fadillah Yusof told Parliament the remaining concessionaires are not making a profit as their numbers of highway users are insufficient.

"In total, there are 30 concessionaires. From this, only five made a profit due to (sufficient numbers of) road users.

"The rest have yet to make a profit because their numbers of road users are still not enough," Fadillah said during Question Time, in response to Irmohizam Ibrahim (BN-Kuala Selangor).

He said this after Irmohizam asked the government's view on reducing toll rates, with the numbers road users continuing to increase.

However, Fadillah did not reveal the names of the concessionaires or the profits they were making.

If certain highways start to become congested, he said, it was the duty of concessionaires to upgrade, as was now being done by PLUS on the North-South Expressway.

On another matter, Abdul Hadi Awang (PAS-Marang) said he was worried about Putrajaya taking instructions from wealthy foreigners in its eagerness to implement the goods and services tax (GST).

"I am concerned that this advice (to implement GST) is coming from overseas 'Qarun', such as the International Monetary Fund and financial scoundrels, including those in our country," Hadi said.

Qarun is a Quaranic figure who was arrogant and spoilt by enormous wealth.

Hadi said the GST would not be necessary if the country was prudent in managing its finances.

However, Shabudin Yahya (BN-Tasek Gelugor) interjected, saying the GST was needed to strengthen the country's fiscal integrity. -Malaysiakini

GST Bill 2014 passed


Tuesday, 08 April 2014 06:30

The Dewan Rakyat this Monday morning passed the Goods and Services Tax (GST) Bill 2014. This bill was passed through a head count twice with the opposition giving only 81 votes and the government, 118 votes in the first round. In the second voting, the opposition maintained with 81 votes while the government voting increased to 119 votes.

Earlier, when winding up the debate on the bill, the Deputy Finance Minister Datuk Ahmad Maslan said that the GST would have positive implications on the value of exports and also on the Gross Domestic Product. "Exports will rise by 0.5 per cent as exported goods will be cheaper and more competitive and the GDP on the whole will rise by 0.3 per cent," he informed. Ahmad said that the GST structure in Malaysia encompassed exemptions on various goods and services to meet the needs of their people. Compared to Singapore, the implementation of GST was imposed on all goods and services and exemptions were only given to the financial services and residential houses, he debated.

"The GST rate of six per cent set by the government is consistent with the current economic situation after taking into consideration several factors including reduction of personal tax and corporate tax and the cash financial assistance, "Ahmad said. -oyetimes.com

Wednesday, April 2, 2014

Anti-GST rally planned for May 1


Wednesday, 02 April 2014 06:11

An anti-Goods and Services Tax (GST) protest will be held on May 1, with a rally planned from Dataran Merdeka to the Kuala Lumpur City Centre (KLCC) iconic Twin Tower.

A committee for the rally however said the details of the rally has yet to be worked out since they would have to work it out with the authorities.

A coalition of some 90 non-governmental organisations and Pakatan Rakyat parties would mobilise Malaysians for the rally, to send a clear message against the government that could possibly enforce the tax beginning Apr next year.

Committee member Dr Hatta Ramli said the next 30 days would be spent to work out on the logistics for the rally, meant to send a "clear message" to the government.

Hatta who is also PAS central working committee member said the introduction of the tax would only burden the people further especially to the lower income group who did not need to pay for income tax.

He also pointed out that the introduction of the GST was the result of the failure of the current government to work on the current tax system especially the high income earner who manage to evade tax.

"It is a short cut way to victimise the defenceless public," he said in a press conference held by the committee here. ;

The press conference was also attended by other committee members including Parti Sosialis Malaysia (PSM) secretary general S. Arutchelvan and Parti Keadilan Rakyat (KeADILan) strategy director Rafizi Ramli.

Arutchelvan said if the public did not make a protest this year, they would end up having to put up with GST "April Fools" joke next year.

He pointed out that many carricatures and cartoons use for the GST campaign.

The rally - themed ‘GST - Protest till it is dropped’ - also aimed to draw the participation of students, who will be among the hardest hit by the tax due to be imposed from April next year.

Rally coordinator E. Parameswari said May 1 rallies have been held in Malaysia since 1994, but hoped that this will be the biggest yet in terms of turnout.

Among the NGOs who have pledged support are Solidariti Anak Muda Malaysia, Turun, Kuala Lumpur Selangor Chinese Assembly Hall, Oppressed People's Network and Himpunan Hijau.

Other issues to be highlighted include the ongoing demand for a minimum wage of RM1,500, fair and free elections, environmental protection, free education, and the rights of women workers and migrant workers.

Rafizi said Pakatan parliamentarians would go all out to fight the Bill in the Dewan Rakyat and even in the courts.

He said the party also backs street rallies as an alternative democratic route as "BN is only afraid of the people's power". -Harakahdaily

Wednesday, March 26, 2014

WAY TOO MUCH! GST awareness campaign will cost RM365 million


The unpopular goods and services tax (GST) will take RM365 million from public coffer to get it running by April next year.

The figure was provided by Finance Ministry in a parliamentary reply to Shah Alam MP Khalid Samad yesterday.

Breaking down the RM365 million, RM17 million is allocated to promote GST awareness campaign, RM100 million for business operators and the biggest chunk RM250 million will be spent on a computer system and new software.

Khalid blasted the government questioning the logic to utilise such huge funding to implement a system that would burden the people in the end.

“Before anything, the government has to carry a burden of RM365 million to implement GST. The people’s money is just to add burden to the people.

They said GST is good because (the people) do not need to pay more. This is like campaigning that the medicine is good because you don’t need the medicine. This is misleading,” jibed the PAS central committee member. -Harakahdaily

Thursday, March 20, 2014

'GST a boon for residential properties'


Thursday, 20 March 2014 05:53

KUALA LUMPUR - The upcoming introduction of the goods and services tax (GST) would positively impact the residential property sector as investors would likely invest in residential segment this year rather than next year.

Talhar & Wong Sdn Bhd managing director Foo Gee Jen said this is because many perceive that the price of houses could be higher in 2015 when the GST is introduced.

"The perception now is that residential developers are going to transfer the additional costs to the buyers once GST is implemented. So people would think that they are going to pay more.

"This would result in the buyers deciding to purchase houses this year instead of next year," he told a media briefing on property market ,here, yesterday.

This, Foo said, would push the demand for residential property as well as its prices.

The GST will be implemented in Malaysia by April 2015.

Meanwhile, the residential demand, particularly affordable housing, will remain highly fuelled by a rapidly growing population of adults between the ages of 25 and 54 and expanding middle-income groups.

Foo said the mid-segment rental market will remain upbeat on the back of a healthy growth in housing demand.

He believes that the overall residential market would remain healthy although the high level of household debt is likely to weigh down on buyers' purchasing ability.

In 2013, the housing market was upbeat with an estimated total of 12,808 new units of terraced, semi-detached and detached houses launched.

The new supply for 2014 is estimated to fall to some 9,800 units in total namely 1,000 detached, 1,800 semi-detached and 70,00 terraced units, Foo said.

He said this year, developers will face the threat of rising construction cost fuelled by higher oil prices and rising material costs.

The cost hike has led developers to build units of smaller floor areas, he said, adding that smaller units are increasingly more popular since they are affordable to a larger segment of prospective buyers. -NST

Friday, November 15, 2013

GST will have ripple effects on M'sian society - expert



KUALA LUMPUR - The challenge of the goods and services tax (GST) is not in its introduction, but the actual implementation where it will create both positive and negative ripple effects on society, a tax expert said.

"The government is trying its very best to gain acceptability in GST, which is a losing battle as tax has never been acceptable to any tax-paying member of society," Taxand Malaysia Sdn Bhd co-founder and chairman Dr Veerinderjeet Singh said.

He said the government's tolerance towards industries will create problems.

"Some ministers have actually said that they are willing to listen to some industries for exemptions and if this is allowed, it will never end," Dr Veerinderjeet said.

"No one likes paying tax and asking for zero-rated items means that you pay nothing, the government gets nothing, and paying nothing is not good for the nation that's already in a critical state of fiscal deficit.

"As it is, the list of zero-rated items is already quite extensive and my concern is that this list will grow longer, given the political climate of this country," he explained.

Dr Veerinderjeet said by allowing breaks on personal tax and an extensive list of zero-rated items, it is inadvertently minimising the potential generated revenue of the GST.

"There will be a lot of complaints when the GST is implemented, due to limited knowledge on the tax itself and unscrupulous traders, who instead of recalculating their products and services, will just charge the additional six per cent for profit.

"For the consumer side, I suggest that the government start a hotline for complaints. Consumers should be able to pick up the phone and make complaints if they think traders are taking advantage through the GST. The government has to do their part by following these complaints in order to protect the Malaysians," he said.

Wednesday, October 23, 2013

GST can make prices of goods & services CHEAPER - finance ministry sec-gen





Malaysians can enjoy cheaper goods and services for many basic necessities if the government implements the goods and services tax (GST), replacing the existing sales and service tax (SST).

The tax, likely to be implemented by 2015, will see a proposed rate of four per cent to replace the current narrowly-applied 10 per cent sales tax and six per cent services tax.

The GST will be levied on the consumption of goods and services at all stages of the supply chain.

If implemented, some 40 basic food necessities, including rice, sugar, milk powder and flour will be listed as zero-tax items, while essential services, such as healthcare, may be classified as tax-exempt.

Most of the items were currently being taxed under the SST and the transition to GST could ease burden on the poor, Secretary-General of Ministry of Finance, Tan Sri Dr Mohamad Irwan Serigar Abdullah, was quoted as saying.

The GST will ensure that the prices of the items will not increase.

Besides that, not all products will be charged the full tax under the proposed GST as certain products will be charged only half of the GST rate.

"The GST is a must, it's not an option," Irwan Serigar said, adding that should the new tax regime be implemented, the government was confident of trimming the fiscal deficit of gross domestic product by 2015 and hitting a surplus by 2020.

Meanwhile, MIDF Amanah Investment Bank Bhd Senior Vice-President/Head of Research, Zulkifli Hamzah, said although the implementation of GST was inflationary, it would only be in the short term as consumption patterns adjusted over time.

"We expect the GST to have a transitory inflationary impact on prices, similar to the evidence found in many countries which have introduced the tax.

"The inflationary impact of the GST will depend on the rate to be decided, exemptions and parallel measures to mitigate price rises," he told Bernama.

The Malaysian Customs Department is of the view that GST's inflationary impact will be minimal as basic and essential foodstuff will be zero-rated and public amenities will be exempted.

Another factor is the lower production cost as GST paid on inputs is claimable by businesses, while savings from the input tax credits should be passed on to the consumers in the form of lower prices.

GST, a broad-based consumption tax, or value-added tax, was first tabled at the Dewan Rakyat in Dec 16, 2009 to replace the current SST, but was withdrew last year for amendments.

The transition will be part of the fiscal reforms undertaken by the government to reduce fiscal deficits and achieve a neutral balanced budget by 2020, helping the country to move towards a high-income economy as well as to achieve a developed nation status.

Economist opined that now was the right time to implement the GST as part of efforts to bolster government revenue.

Once implemented at a revenue-neutral rate of four per cent, the new tax was estimated to rake in a revenue of RM18 billion, which was quite similar to the current revenue of RM16 billion to RM17 billion from sales and services taxes at an average rate of seven per cent.

It is anticipated that Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak will announced the GST in the Budget 2014 on Oct 25.

The GST would take 14 months to be implemented after it was announced.

-- BERNAMA




Monday, October 21, 2013

GST rate may be less than 16% - Ahmad Maslan


Sunday, 20 October 2013 21:23

MELAKA - The tax to be levied under the goods and service tax (GST) may be less than 16%, that is, the amount under the existing sales and services tax (SST) system, says Deputy Finance Minister Datuk Ahmad Maslan.

He also did not see the new tax being a burden to the people.

"If we look at other countries that have implemented the GST, it is less than 16%," he told reporters here today.

He had earlier officiated the High Performance Organisational Leadership Seminar at the Royal Malaysian Customs Academy at Bukit Baru, with the participation of 100 customs officers from throughout the country.

Also present was the Customs Department Deputy Director General Datuk Zainul Abidin Taib.

According to Ahmad, the government began looking at the GST in 2005 and planned for its implementation two years later, but had to postpone this due to a number of reasons, including objections from certain quarters.

He said the rate and date of implementation of the GST may be announced by Prime Minister and Finance Minister Datuk Seri Najib Abdul Razak when he tables the Budget 2014 on Oct 25.

Two days ago, Ahmad had hinted at the possibility of the much talked-about GST not being implemented under the Budget 2014.

Meanwhile, the Deputy Finance Minister said the Customs Department had collected RM25.8 billion as of last Thursday for 2013.

He expressed confidence that RM34.4 billion would be collected by the department by year-end. – Bernama

Monday, October 14, 2013

WATCH OUT GUYS, TALK OF GST IS REAL! Brace yourself for hard times ...



Saturday, 12 October 2013 09:35
Written by Christopher Fernandez, Malaysia Chronicle

With the economy spewing and sputtering, there is a widespread fear and belief in the country that the Barisan Nasional (BN) government is set to impose a Goods & Services Tax (GST) that is set to witness the disposable incomes of the majority of Malaysians drop further.

Since it was discovered that only 16 per cent of Malaysian workers pay taxes, the BN government has come up with this cunning of GST to ensure that everyone contributes to the financial coffers of the country.

With about 82 per cent of the workforce in the low income group, earning less than RM2, 000 a month, all this is really a smack in the face for those of us who harbor the Malaysian dream of becoming a high income nation.

When a boisterous and buoyant Najib Tun Razak became prime minister, he promised to make Malaysia a high income nation. What we have since been witness to is that the nation is not becoming a high income country but beset by heavy taxes on the people.

Besides this, of greater concern, despite contradictory views by the Malaysian Employers Federation (MEF), the wages and salaries of the workforce have not risen in harmony with the cost of living and inflationary trends.

Except perhaps for the government sector, where the BN government takes great pains to ensure civil servants are buffered and cushioned from the effects of an economy that has been witnessing a price spiral ever since Najib took over the reins of power.

This imbalance between the public and the private sector, where the private sector is responsible for producing the greater level of productivity is beginning to cause Malaysians as consumers to wonder how long they will be able to sustain their present standard of living.

It does not help that the Third Force or migrant workers are competing with the locals for a greater share of the economic pie. This unbridled, uncontrolled arrival of streams of migrant workers arriving on our shore has heated up the competition.

This means the Malaysian private sector workers is under great threat and stress from all sides and now with the expected imposition of GST they are most certainly going to become under a greater amount of hardship and suffering.

Brace yourself for hard times Malaysians

Having to butter their bread is now becoming a hard, harsh issue for Malaysians and more and more are declaring bankruptcy in the form of mounting household debts. While the latest household debt level is not available from Bank Negara Malaysia, Malaysians can be assured the figures are worrisome and have increased.

All people have to do is cross-check with neighbors, colleagues, family members and friends and relatives and discover the honest truth that most Malaysians are under dire stress from having to cope with credit card debt, housing and personal loans and business gone awry.

The reason for this, for the Malaysian consumer being put under great stress, is due to the haphazard and short-sighted financial policies and planning of the Malaysian finance ministry. The shifting policies of the ministry, acting according to their whims and fancies, have not helped ease the plight of Malaysians.

Of greater concern is that at a later stage, besides the imposition of GST, there will also come about the withdrawal of all government subsidies on essential goods. While as usual the government sector will be kept afloat by government funds obtained from the tax payer, the vast majority of the Malaysian workforce in the private sector is set to flounder.

It does not help that the various state consumer associations under the umbrella of the Federation of Malaysian Consumer Associations (FOMCA) has upped the ante and gone on a nationwide crusade to ask and assist Malaysians to tighten the belt.

The foray of consumer associations might mean well in the short term. But the Malaysian worker in the New Millennium has come under much hardship and pressure to boost productivity while being denied the right to enjoy the full bounty of their labor.

This oppression of great proportions to squeeze the Malaysian private sector worker and to make him pay for the government and civil servants to sit pretty is tantamount to abuse of workers. The imposition of GST, if it is to take place, which seems like a certainty, will tighten the noose on private sector workers.

It is a crying shame that on one hand, while the private sector is running from pillar to post to try and boost productivity, the public sector is bloated with personnel with the work of an individual staff being done by a total of four or five persons.

While this is a luxury the private sector can ill afford, it is a crying shame to see the pampered status of civil servants a large number of whom are redundant, deadwood employees who are mere passengers being carried by the Malaysian government omnibus.

This sector can easily afford the comforts of life because of unfair partisan politics played by the BN government. It is high time that this disproportionate advantage stop and redress action be taken to eradicate the favoritism of a particular race.

If this is not done quickly the malady that affects the Malaysian consumer will begin to seep into the consciousness of the nation and cause widespread unhappiness and discontent. This will spill over into trouble and the streets will be full of protesters calling for a halt and stop to the BN government’s unfair policies and tactics.

Danger looms among the Malaysian consumer

While the BN government sits quite pretty with billions of ringgit collected by the Lembaga Hasil Dalam Negeri (Inland Revenue Board) annually, it must be noted that a considerable amount of tax paying money goes a begging in the form of corruption as highlighted by the Auditor-General’s Annual Reports.

This is because of a lack of prudence and good housekeeping skills by the Treasury officials who are to be held accountable for irresponsible handling of the wealth of the rakyat. The people’s money is held in trust by the government and thus far there has been no real openness and transparency by the government as to the revenue they collect in taxes from the people and corporations.

With the expected introduction of GST, which is clearly an unnecessary burden on the rakyat, the people have to come out in full force to reject the demands being imposed by a corrupt and greedy regime. The present strata of taxes imposed are sufficient to see to the administration of Malaysia adequately without the imposition of GST.

Malaysian consumers of all walks of life must come down hard on just another ploy by the BN government to fuel its nasty wish of exploiting the masses for its convenience. Power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely.

It is high time for Malaysians and even for the opposition to push for a motion of “no confidence” in the BN government if they wish to impose the Draconian GST. Pakatan Rakyat (PR) must challenge the wish of the BN government to impose GST and pave the way for fresh polls to be conducted as the majority of Malaysians are dead set against the imposition of GST and the BN’s way of governance.

Malaysia Chronicle


Monday, October 7, 2013

Anwar promises to lead nationwide protests if GST implemented in Budget 2014


Monday, 07 October 2013 08:01
Written by Malaysia Chronicle

KUALA LUMPUR - As national unease rises over an expected slew of price hikes, Opposition Leader Anwar Ibrahim promised to lead nationwide protests if Prime Minister Najib Razak implements a Goods and Services Tax (GST) in the upcoming Budget 2014, due to be presented on October 25.

Anwar's Pakatan Rakyat colaition has fought the sales tax for years, arguing that it will further burden the people although it might make the tax collection process more efficient for the government.

"We will not only oppose the GST tabling in Parliament, but also organise protests in the entire country," The Sundaily reported Anwar as saying at a press conference held in Seberang Jaya on Sunday.

Seberang Jaya assemblyman Dr Afif Bahardin was also at the press conference.

Anwar, who is the Permatang Pauh MP, said all the parties in the Pakatan coalition had already reached a consensus against the tabling of the GST.

Coming after the recent 20-sen hike in RON95 petrol price, Anwar said the implementation of GST would seriously deplete the already lean disposable income of the people, who were already struggling with soaring food and transportation prices.

The GST, if implemented, will be imposed on goods and services at every production and distribution stage in the supply chain, including importation of goods and services.

Follow us: @MsiaChronicle on Twitter

Wednesday, August 28, 2013

SPIKE in crime bad for the economy - business leaders


Monday, 26 August 2013 15:57
SPIKE in crime bad for the economy - business leaders
The spate of violent crimes in the country is affecting the country's economy as investors and locals are being frightened away.

This was the general consensus of the local Chinese business community who have expressed their concern on the impact of crime on their livelihood.

This is following a sharp rise in shooting cases nationwide - at least one case a day has been reported since early last month.

Association of Chinese Chambers of Commerce and Industry of Malaysia (ACCCIM) president Datuk Lim Kok Cheong (pic) has urged the government to increase its efforts in curbing violent crimes in the country.

"People feel scared and they don't commit to investments. Even our own people don't come out at night,” MalaysiaKini reported him as saying today.

"The government has to take the necessary steps, there are firearms everywhere.”

What was worse, he pointed out, was that prominent figures who could afford to employ their own security guards have also fallen victims to criminals.

“If senior people in government also kena (fall victim)... what about normal people?”

ACCCIM commerce committee chairperson Leong Kai Hin concurred, noting that while the body has not received any complaints from its 30,000 businessmen and association members, the impact on the economy was unvoidable.

“Most people tend not to come out at night to shop or to visit restaurants (due to crime) and this will affect the economy,” he said.

Police figures revealed that violent crimes have recorded an increase of 7.4% in the first six months of this year (15,098 cases) compared with the same period last year (14,811 cases). However, index crimes have shown a 2.7% decrease within the same period.

Meanwhile, on the goods and service tax (GST) that is being considered by the government, Lim noted that most members have “accepted the eventuality of the tax".

This was based on the results of a survey conducted by the ACCCIM on the economic condition in Malaysia for the first half of the year. Out of the 717 questionnaires sent out to members, 392 were returned.

Most of the respondents, however, urged the government to start at a lower GST bracket and to give a two-year grace period for implementation.

- themalaysianinsider.com


Tuesday, August 27, 2013

40 basic necessities to be exempted from GST




IPOH, (Bernama) -- About 40 basic necessities, including flour, rice and sugar, will be exempted from goods and services tax (GST), said Second Finance Minister, Datuk Seri Ahmad Husni Hanadzlah.

Ahmad Husni said a study was being undertaken and the laws relating to GST would be debated in Parliament next year.

"We are now holding talks with the non-governmental organisations and corporations before any decision on the GST and this will take into consideration the well-being of the rakyat," he told a media briefing after opening a surau in Kampung Kuang Hilir here today.

He said the GST was not a new tax but one to replace the current sales and service tax.

"The GST, which has been implemented in up to 170 nations, is more efficient, modern and has helped boost their economies," he said.

Ahmad Husni said with the implementatin of GST, the nation's income would increase and this would enable the government to consider increasing the payment for Bantuan Rakyat 1Malaysia and reducing the corporate tax.

"We must find ways to reduce the corporate tax to attract more foreign investors to boost economic growth and provide more jobs for the rakyat," he said.

He said the ministry has completed the Budget 2014 consultation sessions held in Sabah and Sarawak.

- mysinchew.com


Tuesday, August 13, 2013

DON'T use Fitch downgrade to negative as an EXCUSE to impose GST - Tony warns Najib



Monday, 05 August 2013 04:00
Written by Tony Pua

Dato’ Seri Najib Razak must not use the excuse of the Fitch Ratings’ revision of Malaysia’s outlook to negative to impose the Goods and Services Tax (GST).

According to Bloomberg, the Government has emailed a statement to reiterate that “Malaysia remains committed to trimming the deficit to 3 percent of gross domestic product by 2015 and won’t let state debt exceed 55 percent of GDP”, and at the same time, “it still plans to reduce subsidies and broaden the tax base”. This statement was made in response to Fitch Ratings revision of Malaysia’s outlook to negative.

We call upon the Datuk Seri Najib Razak not to punish Malaysians with a Goods and Services Tax (GST) for the wastages, leakages and corruption which has caused the Malaysian government to suffer from a record 15 continuous years budget deficit and sky-rocket federal government debt.

Resource rich but still in deficit: Contrast with S'pore

Unlike other resource-starved countries, Malaysia is blessed with revenue from rich natural resources. According to former Prime Minister, Tun Dr Mahathir himself, Petronas has contributed up to RM426 billion as at 2009, and that sum would have increased by another RM260 billion since. Given such extraordinary contributions from the sector, with more than RM60 billion in contributions annually in recent years, Malaysia should be enjoying annual record surpluses instead of suffering from a persistent budget deficit.

In fact, Tun Dr Mahathir himself, who is also the Petronas advisor, has asked in July 2009, “what did the government spend with the RM253.6 billion payment from the national oil company over the past six years” when his successor Tun Abdullah Ahmad Badawi was prime minister.

The above is reflected by the increase in Government revenue by leaps and bounds from only RM93 billion in 2003 to an expected RM209 billion in 2013. That is a massive increase of 125% over just a decade.

The question must be asked as to why is it that despite revenues increasing so ever healthily, an envy of many nations, the BN-led Federal Government has been completely helpless in getting out of the deficit rut. The situation has deteriorated to the revision of Malaysia’s credit rating outlook to negative, which if not met with the right policy responses, will result in a disastrous downgrade.

GST could not save Greece

The immediate policy by the Government it appears to be to “broaden the tax base” by implementing the much discussed GST. However, will GST help resolve the Federal Government’s deficit crisis? In the short term, of course it would. In fact, the easiest way to reduce the deficit for the Government is by increasing the taxes on every person and every product in this country. However, will such measures be just a “panadol” which give temporary relief, but fails to cure the underlying cancer in Malaysia’s public finances?

If GST is a cure, then Greece would never have gone “bankrupt”. Spain, Ireland, Portugal and Italy would not have been in financial crisis. The standard GST or value-added tax (VAT) rate in Greece is 23%. It is the same for Spain, Ireland, Portugal while it is 21% for Italy. Did the VAT or GST save these countries from a crisis arising from persistent deficits?

The answer is an obvious “no”. And if the GST couldn’t save all these nations from plunging into severe economic crisis, why should it be any different in Malaysia?

Postpone the crisis

The simple reason to the above is that the GST will only postpone a crisis by boosting the revenue of the Government. However, if the Government continues to spend wastefully, run inefficiently and be embroiled in the cancer of cronyism and corruption, then no amount of taxes raised from the man-in-the-street will be able to prevent Malaysia from plunging into a crisis sooner or later.

In fact, the more the Government collects from taxes, the more leakages there will be. This correlates directly with the fact that our country’s debts have continued to accelerate despite the massive increase in government revenues, particularly from the oil and gas sectors over the past decade.

Instead of the GST becoming the ‘reform’ measure, the attempt to broaden the tax base in will fact become the hindrance to the much needed real reforms of reducing the reliance of off-balance sheet financing or contingent liabilities, enforcing open and competitive tenders for all government procurement and privatisation contracts, as well as to increase transparency at all levels of the government’s budgeting processes to fight corruption.

If the Prime Minister really believes that the Fitch warning “is a concern that we share as a government and [the Government] would seek to address those concerns”, then he must heed our call in upcoming Budget and not impose the unnecessary burden of additional taxes on ordinary Malaysians, 85% of whom still do not earn enough to qualify to pay income taxes today.

Tony Pua is the DAP MP for PJ Utara



Follow us: @MsiaChronicle on Twitter

Thursday, June 20, 2013

Don't force GST on the people to fund your Maharaja lifestyle - Anwar warns Najib


Wednesday, 19 June 2013 11:39

Written by Wong Choon Mei, Malaysia Chronicle

Don't force GST on the people to fund your Maharaja lifestyle - Anwar warns Najib
UPDATED VIDEO INSERTED Opposition Leader Anwar Ibrahim warned Prime Minister Najib Razak not to introduce a new Goods and Service Tax (GST) to reduce the budgetary deficit after the latter announced the formation of a special committee to look into ways to reduce the shortfall - at a record high - to 3% bt 2015.
"Unfortunately, Dato Seri Najib continues to govern behind a veil of secrecy," Anwar told a press conference on Wednesday.
"The BN government must not drag the public to cover for its economic incompetence and policy shortfalls. Any attempts to introduce a new GST albeit in stages to reduce the deficit will be resisted in the same force that the people had resisted electoral fraud."
Anwar was referring to the Black 505 rallies, a people's movement spearheaded by the Pakatan Rakyat to protest vote rigging and fraud in the May 5 general election. The hugely successful rallies have drawn more than half a million Malaysians to assemble to demand the resignation of the Election Commission leadership.
Just PM's Office alone - RM4 BILLION a year?
The 64-year-old Anwar also chided Najib for his 'free-spending' ways, challenging the latter, who is also the Finance Minister, to refute the Opposition's estimate that just the prime minister's office alone spent at least RM4 billion a year on "huge entourages and thousands of personnel".
"The minister concerned has alluded to the fact that they need RM27 billion in extra revenue or the deficit problem will remain. Our position differs completely with the BN's. Our position is consistent in that you must start with transparent policies, which means you save billions, stop excessive spending, reduce the exorbitant excessive expenditure of the Prime Minister's Office, the huge entourage, thousands of personnel and that would already be in the billions," said Anwar.
"In fact, our initial estimate is that at least RM4bil alone (in budget allocation) is for the Prime Minister's Maharaja-type of expenditure. And I would challenge him to refute this, which is unprecedented throughout all my experience as Finance Minister and the history of this country."
PKR secretary-general Saifuddin Nasution was also present at the press conference.
Hardship to the people as wage growth has been weak
According to Anwar, GST could only be introduced if the average level of income of "common Malaysians" have risen significantly over a period of 5 years, otherwise it would bring hardship to the working classes. He pointed to the fact that the current wage reality in Malaysia was that only a "low 2.6% average wage growth" had been achieved between 2000 and 2010.
"In 10 years, the wage increase was only 2.6%. Given that scenario, it is unacceptable to imagine the government would introduce additional taxes, GST for example. So what we are saying is stop the wastage first. We are talking about RM20 to 30 billion of commissions and bribery, extraneous spending. Look at the Auditor-General's report, this must be addressed first.
"Dato Seri Najib does not have the full legitimacy in terms of popular votes, and he has not been able to deliver the most basic of his economic promises since being sworn in recently. That fact that his administration struggles to reduce car prices as promised in his manifesto exemplified he incompetence and hopelessness of his administration."
Anwar also took Najib to task for failing to keep pre-election promises of cheaper cars and affordable homes. He warned that the Pakatan Rakyat would be monitoring runaway property prices closely and would expect to see prices come down by at least 10%.
"We shall track the BN government's performance on public housing closely and will consider it a failure if he cannot bring down the average prices of mid-range housing by at least 10% in the next one year," said Anwar.
Malaysia Chronicle


Full article: http://www.malaysia-chronicle.com/index.php?option=com_k2&view=item&id=116131:do#ixzz2dEMt5mWx 

Tuesday, May 21, 2013

M'sians still can't afford to pay GST, what more at 7% start rate - Wong Chen ticks off Idris Jala



Monday, 20 May 2013 11:38Written by Wong Choon Mei, Malaysia Chronicle

UPDATED VIDEO INSERTED PETALING JAYA - Unlike in Singapore, the Malaysian government's plan to implement Goods and Services Tax is regressive as the majority of Malaysians already find it burdensome to make ends meet, and the only ones to benefit would be the corporate fat cats and business cronies of the political elite, an Opposition leader said on Monday.

Based on newly-elected Member of Parliament for Kelana Jaya Wong Chen's numbers, 88% of Malaysia's 28 million population do not pay tax as they fall below the taxable level.

Meanwhile, due to decades of pump-priming the economy with mega infrastructure projects - many of which have turned into white elephants - Malaysia's national debt is at an all-time high and even by official estimates nearly breaching the 55% ceiling imposed by law.

Analysts however believe the 55% level has already been breached as the government - in computing the figures - have not included the loans and debts of government-linked firms such as public utilities Tenaga and Telekom as well national car maker Proton, which the experts have said they should.

As such, the GST is seen as a lifeline for the BN government to alleviate the pressure on the growing fiscal deficit. But its proposal has met stiff resistance from a public already struggling with high costs of transportation and food.

'PKR notes that the BN government is facing a fiscal crisis of its own doing. PKR believes that the 3 main causes of this crisis are as follows: a weak tax base, profligate spending and unabated corruption," Wong Chen told a press conference on Monday.

"The PKR stand is that - show us that you are willing to cut corruption, what have you done to reduce mega projects and can you balance your books (fiscal position). If you do these and still can't balance your books, then you are entitled to consider introducing GST but start at a very low level and not at 7%. Don't give us the lip service, show us the savings, For example the MRT is good but does it have to cost RM60billion - seriously guys?"



Don't try to pass the bill for BN's excesses to the main on the street to pay

Wong Chen slammed the BN for allegedly trying to pick on the man on the street to pay off serious financial problems that it has brought onto itself and the nation.

"We understand the rationale for GST is to widen and improve the existing tax base. However, the current weak tax base is not a matter of tax evasion per se but a reflection of the poor household earnings of the majority of Malaysians. The majority of Malaysians simply do not have sufficient income to pay income tax," said Wong, who also heads the PKR investment bureau.

"The current problem of a weak tax base is about low pay and income security. Therefore the rationalse for BN's GST tax plan to widen the tax base is in fact flawed. Promising corporate and income tax cuts to offset GST will only help the rich. In other words, BN's GST plan is regressive in nature and will essentially see the poor end up paying more than the rich."

Why 7% - who can afford?

Wong took to task Prime Minister Najib Razak, who is also the Finance Minister, for trying to push through an "exorbitantly high" 7% GST rate. He pointed to the Singapore example that officials in the Malaysian Finance Ministry such as Minister in the PM's Office Idris Jala have been alluding to in the press as a model for Malaysians to follow.

"Lastly, Idris Jala cited the current Singapore GST rate iof 7% as a model for Malaysia. This is an alarming departure from the 4% rate that is being proposed by the Ministry of Finance," said Wong Chen.

"We wish to remind the Minister that when Singapore introduced GST in 1994, it was a low rate of 3% and the Singapore government kept it low for 9 years before allowing an increase to 4% in 2003. It only increased to 7% in 2007, 13 years after GST was introduced. If the Minister loves the Singapore model so much, will he commit to 3% with a 9-year no-hike moratorium?"

Malaysia Chronicle

Read more: http://www.malaysia-chronicle.com/index.php?option=com_k2&view=item&id=102211:malaysians-still-cannot-afford-to-pay-gst-what-more-at-7-start-rate-wong-chen&Itemid=2#ixzz2YVR4VlGi
Follow us: @MsiaChronicle on Twitter