GST EVENT CALENDAR

GST MALAYSIA CALCULATOR

Nuffnang Add

Showing posts with label KosongCafeBlog. Show all posts
Showing posts with label KosongCafeBlog. Show all posts

Monday, October 14, 2013

Why fret over GST?


As far as I am concerned, with the GE13 over, and the two top posts in Umno went unchallenged, the introduction of GST is a given, come this Budget Day.

Despite numerous articles on the proposed GST, a retired teacher told us at breakfast: 'I read Dr. Fong Chan Onn's article, but still cannot understand.' I can understand why. Normally, someone with a Ph D tends to be verbose and lengthy in their explanation, except, Dr Zahid, who is best at swift solutions like 'shoot first', based on racial prejudice and 'criminal look'. I wonder how he defended his Ph D thesis 5 years ago.

Anyway, I do not understand why the retiree bother to try and understand the workings of GST, when as a consumer, he could just get used to the new prices after implementation, just like before, whenever there was a change for one reason or other.

As a consumer, he does not need to register for GST nor need to account for it. Just pay whatever is charged. He does not need to know whether the shop is properly registered nor whether they account for the tax properly.

Whether we have been overcharged, with or without a reason, the best solution is just to boycott the shop or stall. There is no use in arguing nor being right, backed with facts and figures.

I have tried before: trying to explain certain things, but would give up when I got interrupted or I noticed the listener losing interest or attention. The same retiree's standard joke when approached by someone who tried to introduce some investment plans: I'm interested in months, preferably days... don't tell me anything which is more than a year as I don't think I can live beyond that!

In my opinion, sooner or later, GST will be implemented because of it being a convenient source of revenue and the ease the rate can be adjusted. Even with strong opposition from the opposition and the public, soon the oil will dry up or our extravagant expenditures will see to its introduction to make ends meet.

For a more straightforward explanation of GST...

For an overly simplified example of GST (like using 10% rate)...


Business:                         A B C       Total
Selling price before GST 1.00 1.20 1.50
Value added                          0.20 0.30      0.50

SP after GST @ 10% 1.10 1.32 1.65
GST payable to Govt 0.10 0.02 0.03     0.15


Note:
The GST comprises (0.10 + 0.02 + 0.03) which totalled 0.15 or 10% of final selling price 1.50.
Business A is presumed to have no input GST and therefore pays Govt 0.10 charged to B;
Business B pays net GST (output tax 0.12 charged to C, less input tax 0.10 paid to A) = 0.02.
Business C pays net GST (output tax 0.15 charged to consumer less input tax 0.12 paid to B) = 0.03.

Confused about the existing GST and the proposed GST?


Of course, when the existing GST stand for Govt Service Tax (6%) while the proposed GST stand for Goods and Services Tax. 

To further confuse the people, when government tried to educate the public on the proposed GST, 4% rate was used in various examples. Now, as if to test the reaction of the people as well as the need to increase tax revenue, 7% has been used.

That our government will introduce GST is a matter of time, in preparation for 'an oil-less future', to quote Ms Tan Siok Choo in her excellent article in The Sun:
GST - The political TNT by Tan Siok Choo

To support the case for implementation, examples of Singapore and Norway are likely to be quoted, because both countries are financially sound yet found it necessary to implement this form of indirect tax as a source of government revenue.

To gain general acceptance from the public, I believe our government will introduce GST together with a reduction in personal and/or corporate tax rates as sweetener.

'Again Singapore provides an excellent role model. From 3% GST, the republic progressively raised its GST to the current 7% level. During the same period, it has slashed personal and corporate tax rates to 20% and 17% respectively – among the lowest worldwide.'

Most essential goods and services are likely to be exempted, so that the majority of people are not burdened by its introduction.

We have been through it all before, when GST was first mooted and we were educated on the mechanism of the tax and how it would affect us, the public.

Basically, the main advantage of GST (or VAT in other countries like UK) is that it affects consumers only when they purchase certain goods or use certain services, which implies choice by consumers, unlike direct taxation which affects all those whose incomes are high enough to incur income tax. 

The whole GST system of accounting must be well thought out to prevent unnecessary costs to businesses affected by it; to ensure their proper registration and control to prevent frauds (collecting from public though unregistered or failure to remit due amounts to tax department); only valid bills with proper GST registration number are used in calculation of tax payable or refundable; and so on.

Despite previous public education on GST, I am sure most members of the public are still confused as to the effects on prices of goods and services.
 
Below is an over-simplified example (GST at 4%) to illustrate the confusion:
A carpenter bought Rm100 of wood. He would have paid Rm104 for the wood to the supplier. After making a chair, he charges Rm156 (Rm150 + GST Rm6). He can claim the Rm4 GST on his Input GST from the Rm6 on his Output GST and remit Rm2 to tax department.

To a member of public who bought the chair, he is paying Rm156 which comprise Rm100 wood + GST Rm4 + Rm50 value added by carpenter + GST Rm2. 

The wood supplier needs to remit Rm4 (assuming no Input GST) and the carpenter needs to remit Rm2 (Rm6 - Rm2) to tax department.

I am sure many people are confused by the implication of GST and assume that the 4% (or whatever rate decided) will be added at every value-added stage without deducting the input tax. 

In the above example, public perception is likely to be:

Rm100 + GST Rm4 + Rm50 + Rm6 = Rm160 instead of Rm156, a perceived increase of Rm10 instead of Rm6 as a result of GST. 

As for general implications of the proposed GST, the following picture is quite close to the truth...


but subject to the following:

1. All restaurants presently covered by Govt Service Tax are likely to be included for Goods and Service Tax, only the rate (to be decided) might be different.

2. If an outlet's sales revenue is to be a determinant, then Mamak stalls which are presently excluded are likely to be excluded for the same reason, but the ingredients used (unless exempted) might have included the new GST.

3. Whether eating at home is affected by the new GST would depend on the food purchased - whether from an outlet which charges GST or items which have included GST.

Janji yang pertama ditepati oleh Najib



This picture puts it best, the effects of the new GST (Goods and Services Tax), when compared with the old GST (Government Service Tax).

When we were being educated on GST, the rate used in examples was 4%. Even before introduction, it has been increased to 7% (to test the reaction of the people?), a whopping 75% increase in rate. Even when it was mentioned at 4%, many people like myself, had warned about the possible change in rate at will by the government, once it has been introduced. Well, BN can now claim they have the mandate to introduce GST, long delayed because of their worry over its effects on GE13, and increase the rate if and when necessary (to reduce high deficits).